Smart Intruder Alarms in UK Homes: A Burglar's View

As an ex-burglar with decades of experience of house breaks in the UK, I am really interested in how we have looked to embrace some digital SMART alarm technology to target harden our properties. I have mentioned in other articles for Eyes on Crime that burglars typically employ a risk versus reward mentality and if a house looks too secure, we will target next door or on the next street. So, the “appearance” of security from the outside acts as a useful deterrent effect. From a criminological perspective this is one aspect of the “crime triangle” namely the presence of a suitable “guardian”

It is important however, to not wholly rely on your SMART system alone. I appreciate that these systems offer a range of features designed to enhance security and provide peace of mind, but, like any technological innovation, smart intruder alarms come with both advantages and disadvantages. I have bulleted these below.

---

Pros:

Remote Monitoring and Control Smart intruder alarms enable homeowners to monitor and control their security systems remotely. Through mobile apps, users can receive real-time alerts and even arm or disarm the system from anywhere, offering unparalleled convenience and flexibility.

Integration with Smart Home Ecosystems: Many smart intruder alarms can be integrated seamlessly with other smart home devices. This integration allows for a more comprehensive and interconnected home security system, with the ability to sync alarms with smart locks, cameras, and lighting systems. They can, for instance, spot people like me, walking around your property and allow you to speak to me through your Smart doorbell if you have this as an added feature.

Advanced Detection Technology: Unlike traditional alarm systems, smart intruder alarms often incorporate advanced detection technologies such as motion sensors, glass break detectors, and even artificial intelligence for more accurate threat identification. This can reduce false alarms and enhance the overall effectiveness of the system, but it depends how much you want to pay!

Customization and Personalisation: Homeowners can tailor smart intruder alarms to their specific needs. This customisation allows you to set different security profiles, schedules, and sensitivity levels based on your lifestyle, providing a personalised and adaptive security solution

Solution Costs: These systems are generally coming into the financial reach of many householders, and you can obtain a basic system and build add-ons as you go. As the systems are not hard wired in you can install most systems yourself if you have some digital systems knowledge which saves the cost of installation.

Signage: Most systems provide some stickers to put in your windows as a visible deterrent. In my experience they don’t provide enough which seems daft.

---

Cons:

Initial Cost and Installation OK so there is a cost for a basic system. Ring Systems (2024) will cost between £200-£300 depending on the systems you want. There are cheaper systems out there, but I cannot comment how good they are. As usual any system is only as good as its weakest link. I have older relatives (80s) and they would struggle to set it up themselves as they are not tech savvy so would need someone to help them in this regard.

Reliance on Technology: The effectiveness of smart intruder alarms heavily depends on technology, and any technical malfunctions or system vulnerabilities could compromise security. Power outages, connectivity issues, or software glitches may leave your house temporarily unprotected.

Privacy Concerns: Smart intruder alarms often involve the use of cameras and sensors, raising concerns about privacy. Homeowners must be cautious about the potential misuse of collected data, and the risk of hacking or unauthorized access to the system, which could lead to privacy breaches.

Alarms and Burglars: If, as a burglar, I think you live remotely or without likely signs of assistance I may still take the chance of breaking into your house and triggering your alarm. Most people, (due to cost) don’t sign up for additional links to a mobile security service when their alarm triggers so it will rely on diligent neighbours or passing police to intervene if the alarm triggers and you are not about.

Conclusion

So, there you have it! The installation of a smart intruder alarm in your home comes with a set of advantages and disadvantages that homeowners must carefully consider. While these systems offer advanced features, remote monitoring, and integration with other smart devices, the reliance on technology, privacy concerns, and ongoing maintenance pose challenges. Ultimately, the decision to install a smart intruder alarm should be based on a thorough evaluation of your individual needs, budget constraints, and a willingness to embrace evolving technology in the pursuit of enhanced home security. In my view I think the cost is worth it for that peace of mind but I would opt for a recognised system if your finances can push to it.

Darryl Kennedy: Eyes on Crime Contributor